SIMÕES DE ABREU M., ARCÀ A., FOSSATI F., JAFFE L., 1998. Palaeolithic rock engravings at Vermelhosa, Côa valley archaeological park, Portugal, in UISPP – International Union of Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Proceedings of the XIII Congress, Volume 3, Forlì
| full text-image flip book and PDF | English.
by Mila SIMÕES DE ABREU, Andrea ARCÀ, Angelo FOSSATI, Ludwig JAFFE
Simões De Abreu, Arcà, Fossati, Jaffe 1998, download PDF (1100 Kb)
Flip book details:
- search feature unavailable (bug) in full-screen mode;
- upper bar functions: (left) title, see-go to page numer; (right) search;
- lower bar functions: (left) enable full screen, page thumbnails, PDF download, sound on/off, zoom in/out, search, social share; (right) first-previous-next-last page;
- page double click activates zoom; mouse wheel scrolls pages.
- digitalized with text layer Feb 2014 by TRACCE editing board;
- scan, OCR, search and flip book features by TRACCE editing board;
- public domain.
You may browse and read the flip book up here (search and full-screen features available) or download the related searchable PDF; if you like you may continue reading this online TRACCE page, same content, re-formatted.
(same content, html version)
UNIONE INTERNAZIONALE DELLE SCIENZE PREISTORICHE E PROTOSTORICHE
Membro del Consiglio Intemazionale della Filosofia e delle Scienze Umane
(C.I.P.S.H. – U.N.E.S.C.O.)
UNION INTERNATIONALE DES SCIENCES PRÉHISTORIQUES ET PROTOHISTORIQUES
Membre du Conseil International de la Philosophie et des Sciences Humaines
(C.I.P.S.H. – U.N.E.S.C.O.)
INTERNATIONAL UNION OF PREHISTORIC AND PROTOHISTORIC SCIENCES
Member of the International Council for Philosophy and Humanistic Studies
(C.I.P.S.H. – U.N.E.S.C.O.)
ATTI DEL XIII CONGRESSO
ACTES DU XIII CONGRESS
PROCEEDINGS OF THE XIII CONGRESS
FORLI’ – ITALIA
Section 7 The Mesolithic
Section 8 Art in the Palaeolithic and Mesolithic
Section 9 The Neolithic in the Near East and Europe
1998, by A.B.A.C.O. s.r.l., Forlì, Italy.
121 Palaeolithic rock engravings at Vermelhosa. Coa Valley Archaeological Park. Portugal
PALAEOLITHIC ROCK ENGRAVINGS
AT VERMELHOSA, COA VALLEY
ARCHAEOLOGICAL PARK, PORTUGAL
Mila Simões de Abreu, Andrea Arcà, Angelo Fossati, Ludwig Jaffe
“Etched in time project”, by: AARP – Associação de Arte Rupestre Portuguesa, Av. D. José I, n. 53 – 2780 OEIRAS – PORTUGAL, phone/fax +351-1-457.95.24. “Footsteps of Man “(Cooperativa Archeologica Le Orme dell ‘Uomo) p.zza Donatori di Sangue 1 – 25040 – CERVENO (BS) – ITALY, +39- 304-433.983 fax +39-364-43.43.51
1 – THE DISCOVERY
The great importance of Cõa Valley Rock Art reached the headlines of the Portuguese and international press in November 1994. Even now it is taking a big place in Portuguese research, where a distinct division has been defined between the so called A.C. (Antes do Côa – before the Coa) and D.C. (Depois do Côa – After the Côa) Archaeology.
The Côa Valley area was under the scientific superintendence of Nelson Rebanda, a state Archaeologist, encharged with the Côa Area at the Northern Region Department (Direcção Regional Norte) of IPAAR (Instituto Portugués do Patrimonio Arquitectónico e Arqueológico).
When the Portuguese government decided in 1992 to undertake the construction of a huge new dam on the Côa River, a protocol of collaboration was made between the IPPAR and EDP (Electricidade de Portugal) and Rebanda was put on charge of the “Plano Arquelógico do Côa” (archaeological plan of the Côa).
Following the indications of impact study made by Francisco Sande Lemos (here more then 65 Archaeological sites were described including 3 painted rock shelters and an engraved site) he discovered in 1993, at Canada do Inferno, the first palaeolithic engraved panels in the Côa Valley. Most of the discoveries were made when the level of the Pocinho dam was lowered by 12 meters, leaving out of the water many big pecked figures of aurochs, deers and horses. Other panels were suddenly discovered over the highest water level.
The Dam of Foz Côa was considered a fundamental part of the strategic plan of the Portuguese Government to try to create a major reservoir of water. Its energetic aspect was insignificant and same Port wine producers were against it.
Curiously, no official notice was made of the discoveries by Rebanda’s team. It was only in November 1994 that the Portuguese archaeological community became aware of the findings. An International movement to save the engraved rocks started and a strong campaign to stop the construction of the dam was launched. Television, radio and newspapers transformed the issue in a political case.
Menaced by more than 100 meters of water (and mud) of the future dam many new sites were quickly ‘discovered’ by the local inhabitants along more than 17 km of the Côa river and adjacent Douro river: Ribeira dos Piscos, Vale de Figueira. Peñascosa. Barca. Vale Jose Esteves, Vale Vermelhosa. Vale de Cabrões, revealing with all evidence the existence of a big open air palaeolithic rock art area, one of the most important in Europe.
Anyway the discovery was not unforeseeable:
- in 1981 the so called “Mazouco horse” was discovered (25 km. southern, along the Douro river):
122 XIII U.I.S.P.R Congress Proceedings – Forli. 8-14 September 1996
- in 1988 the area of Siega Verde, in the adjacent Spanish border, was recognized, with more than 500 engraved Palaeolithic pecked figures;
- in 1992 the area of Domingo Garcia (Segovia, Spain) began to be studied.
The more relevant discovery was perhaps the Vale da Casa site, a few km down from the Côa confluence along the Douro river. It was studied (1982) by A. M. Baptista (now with M. V. Gomes he is encharged with the documentation in many sites of Côa Valley area), just before being submerged by the Pocinho Dam. which at the same time submerged many engraved panels in the Côa Valley area. No protest against the dam was made. 23 engraved panels were found (and partially traced or moulded), and more than 100 Bronze Age graves. In the engraved rocks were present (but not recognized as Palaeolithic, simply reported as similar to the Mazouco ones) many scratched animal figures, actually identical to the Côa and Vermelhosa ones.
2 – FROM THE DAM TO THE PARK
The Movement to save Côa Valley engraved rocks was started and led by Mila Simões De Abreu and Ludwig Jaffe, and internationally sustained by many Archaeological scholars. Institutions and Universities (Universidad de Alcalá de Henares. Institut of Archaeology London, Université de Poitiers, British Academy, Society for American Archaeology, University of Bristol, Australian Academy of the Humanities, University of New Mexico…).
After having seen (being invited few hours before the Pocinho dam level elevation) for the first time in November 1994 the engraved rocks, Abreu and Jaffe (AARP Rock Art researchers and IFRAO representatives) immediately realized the capital importance of the site and the absolute necessity of saving it by stopping the building of the dam.
For the first time archaeological researchers, environmental associations and student organizations (note the peculiar slogan ‘As gravuras não sabem nadar – The engravings are not able to swim”), worked together to make possible the creation of an Archaeological Park. The International cooperation was of capital importance, linking scientific advice to media support.
The movement was obviously strongly opposed by EDP and the dam supporters, trying to depreciate the archaeological importance of the engraved panels. In this scenery some “direct dating” values obtained by AMS (A. Watchman) and Microerosion (R.G. Bednarik) methods (under EDP funding, which involved also Dorn and Phillips -Chlorine 36- methods), were utilized in a press campaign, trying to demonstrate a recent dating for the Palaeolithic style figures. The idea was that that if the engravings were Post-Palaeolithic its importance would be inferior. Unsuccessful attempts to sew and mould the rocks were also funded by EDP, damaging in some cases the engraved surfaces.
After a long and passionate “fight”, and after the election of a new government in Portugal, finally in November 1995 the building of the dam was officially “suspended” (but not forsaken), to evaluate the scientific importance of the site and to create a commission for the installation of an Archaeological Park.
These events caused a substantial reorganization of Portuguese Archaeology, with the planned creation of the IPA (Instituto Portuguese de Archeologia, under the Direction of the archaeologist V. O. Jorge) and of the Archaeological Park of Côa Valley.
Thus being in an organizing phase, and under the spontaneous arrival of a large number of national and international tourists, the Park was inaugurated on August 10, 1996, under the direction of the archaeologist J. Zilhão. At the moment guides has been instructed, booklets, records and cards printed, multimedia applications compiled, and two reception centers has been prepared at Vila Nova de Foz Côa and Castelo Melhor. A third center is planned in Moxagata. From these centers tourists can start a guided tour (by the Park Jeeps, only guided visits are allowed) to Canada do Inferno. Ribeira dos Piscos and Peñascosa, the most important
123 Palaeolithic rock engravings at Vermelhosa. Côa Valley Archaeological Park. Portugal
engraved sites. The surveillance is assured by a private agency, previously working for the dam and now for the Park.
It is also important to notice that for the first time a Rock Art area encourages the institution of an economic development plan (called “Pro-Côa”), now funded by the Portuguese Government and the European Union.
With the aim of giving a definitive”status” to the Park (and at the same time to the abandonment of the dam), it will be useful to find the way of enlarging the daily number of tourists (also to extend the local economic involvement), and to preserve the natural environment (by the building of some wood-walks), which can easily turn into a dusty barren land.
An International involvement seems also desirable, to find the way of the best multioriented scientific study, and to locate a wild-like area, to leave engraved rocks free from any human intervention (many surfaces are actually traced after a complete washing and cleaning), to make possible future analysis of patina (dating) and of engraving techniques.
3 – THE VERMELHOSA SITE AND THE “ETCHED IN TIME” PROJECT
The Vermelhosa site is situated in a small lateral little valley on the orographic left side of the Douro river, less than 1 km down from the Côa confluence in the Douro.
The engraved rocks were discovered in June 1995 by José Pilerio, a Vila Nova de Foz Côa researcher.
In this area (and also in most Côa Valley areas) it is easy to find many vertical red surfaces of Xisto Grauvaquico Ante-Ordoviciano, a sedimentary metamorphosed rock where silica, quartz and aluminum components make water erosion quite impossible. So the rocks are very well preserved, not eroded, only (sometimes hardly) affected by the natural detaching of (sometimes large) blocks along the schist fractures.
As in all open air rock art concentrations, the rock itself plays a fundamental role, making possible the execution of the engraved figures. In this sense it is very probable that many other engraved sites are present in the adjacent areas (where the schist is largely diffused), mainly along the Douro river sides, perhaps sorrowfully submerged by the Pocinho dam water.
Looking at the large extension of the open air engraved areas it seems that the common idea of a cave limited hidden Palaeolithic Art is to be differently considered. In the same way the diffused presence of engraved panels close to the river sides, clearly related to the sites of animal watering, probably obliges to shift in this case the definition of a prehistoric “sanctuary”‘ into something more related to the hunting practice and to the seasonal relationship with a vast territory.
Most Côa Valley engravings consist in pecked animal figures. On the contrary engraved rocks at Vermelhosa site show only scratched figures (more common than pecking in Palaeolithic rock art), with representations of animals and of schematic elements.
The work at the Vermelhosa site, still in progress, is conducted by an International (P – I – USA – PL) team (coordinated by M. S. Abreu. A. Arcà, A. Fossati, L. Jaffe) in the joint project of AARP-Footsteps of Man “Gravado no Tempo – Etched in Time”, funded by “Ministerio da Cultura – IPAAR – Plano Nacional de Trabalho Arqueologico”.
In the geological field J. A. Bravo Nunez and S. A. Marques are working, B. Campos and M. Coelho in organization and tracing. P. Firnharber in photographic documentation, J. Kolber in sketching and conservation consultation.
The first traced surfaces, in particular rocks n. 1 and 4. have suddenly offered largely interesting results.
Two points are to be outlined:
- without doubt there is the presence of Palaeolithic kinds of figures: female representations, extinct fauna depiction (Megaceros -fig. 4. a probable Mammoth head -fig. 5, schematic
124 XIII U.I.S.P.P. Congress Proceedings – Forli. 8-14 September 1996
elements (roof-like figures -fig. 8-; undulated bands -fig. 7-; fish-like figures);
2. Iron Age figures (horses and a riding warrior raising a spear -fig. 11-), still white and without patina, cover Palaeolithic ones.
It is not possible for the moment to offer a detailed chronology: many typological comparisons suggest anyway a Solutrean-Magdalenian range.
We can very well compare Vermelhosa scratched figures (in particular of rock no. 1) with:
- animal representations of Escoural Cave;
- roof-like figures of Altamira, Lascaux and Escoural;
- Palaeolithic plaquettes (goat and deer Solutrean shapes, branch-like Magdalenian figures) of Parpallò Cave;
- female images of the engraved Final Magdalenian stone slab of Lalinde, of Pech-Merle, of Hohlenstein, of Gonnersdorf.
Even if stylistic-based chronology has been recently doubted (though by not yet well tested methods), such a large array of comparisons renders statistically unlikely any not Palaeolithic-culture related interpretation. All Côa Valley pecked figures add favorable elements. No not Palaeolithic Rock Art complex, even in the Spanish Levant style, show a similar range of figures, themes and scenes.
The clear evidence of Iron Age figures, whose scratched lines are much whiter than the overlapped Palaeolithic ones, added to the presence in the surrounding area of Bronze Age, Middle Age and contemporary engraved signs, show a complete longtime range, still continuing, where Palaeolithic figures are taking an incontestable place of authenticity and of main European archaeological and cultural interest.
Returning to the Vermelhosa particular evidence, we should add for the descriptive side a probable lion or feline figure -fig. 3-, the representation of a horse-like or gazelle-like figure (also whiskers are scratched) hit by a javelin -fig. 3-, and the particular dorsal lines of two deers, which humps, joined to the large neck, render the figure more similar to a Megaceros than to a Cervus Elaphus -fig. 4-, A particularly big figure shows, though in doubt because of the undemonstrated existence of this animal in Portugal during the Upper Palaeolithic, a Mammoth-like head shape -fig. 2-.
One female figure without a head is depicted in sector A -fig. 5-, apparently inside (or overlapping) a roof-like or hut-like figure. Two other female figures have been detected in sector B: one of them shows head, arms and breast -fig. 6-.
Most of the animals are scratched in a fine way. with a little head and body, head and legs filled by parallel curved lines, depicting coat or muscle shape -fig. 1-. They are oriented to the right size, being probably involved in a large scene.
Regarding the Iron Age. rock no. 4 shows an interesting duel scene, with two warriors handling double pointed spears, with typical head-dress or helmet and ithyphallic attitude -fig. 10-, This scene should be compared with a similar one depicted in a Liria vase.
The documentation work involved (and still involves) complete scientific tracing (contact tracing over transparent plastic sheets with natural or artificially improved grazing light), detailed photographic recording, and geological analysis.
We would like to thank the Portuguese government and archaeological and political authorities who made possible (we hope in a definitive way) with a noble decision the saving of the area and scientific research.
Part of this document is available online in TRACCE Online Rock Art Bulletin n. 5 at:
125 Palaeolithic rock engravings at Vermelhosa. Côa Valley Archaeological Park. Portugal
126 XIII U.l.S.P.P. Congress Proceedings – Forlì. 8-14 September 1996
SIMÕES DE ABREU M., ARCÀ A., FOSSATI F., JAFFE L., 1998. Palaeolithic rock engravings at Vermelhosa, Côa valley archaeological park, Portugal, in UISPP – International Union of Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Proceedings of the XIII Congress, Volume 3, Forlì.